Tuesday, August 25, 2015

Galen Rathbun on Mark-Recapture with Cameras

From: Galen Rathbun <grathbun@gmail.com>
Subject: Re: Fwd: Karura Mammals
Date: 25 August 2015 18:42:04 GMT+3
Reply-To: grathbun@calacademy.org

Thank you for the email, Musila.  I am not sure I have much to contribute on this topic - there should be no sengis in Karura.  I do remember visiting the forest while I was in NBI in the early 70s.  In the last issue of the Journal of Wildlife Management there is a paper on estimating abundance based on camera trap data (without mark-recapture method): JWM 79(6):1014-1021.  If you can not find this paper, let me know and I will scan it for you.  I wish I could contribute more, because Croze was an important adviser to my dissertation work at the U of NBI and I would love to be able to return on his investment in my career (your help has not been forgotten, Harvey!!).  Best, Galen
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Galen B. Rathbun, Ph.D.
Department of Ornithology and Mammalogy
California Academy of Sciences (San Francisco)
c/o P.O. Box 202, Cambria, CA 93428, USA
Office/Home Phone: +1.805.927.3059
Emails: grathbun@calacademy.org or grathbun@gmail.com
www.rathbunX2.com
www.afrotheria.net
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

On 24-Aug-15 5:43 AM, Simon Musila wrote:
Dear Rathbun,
see information from KARURA FOREST AND ADVISE WHERE POSSIBLE
KIND REGARDS

Monday, August 24, 2015

Simon Musila on Suni

From: Simon Musila <surnbirds@gmail.com>
Subject: Re: Karura Mammals
Date: 24 August 2015 15:40:50 GMT+3
To: Harvey Croze <hcroze@karurafriends.org>

Dear Harvey,
Thank you very much for communication; This is very good information. I am delighted to know about the work of FKF. This is amazing research. I think using the existing cameras it is still useful information. It is amazing the kind of data the camera have reported. 
You could share your sightings or postings to a page i manage called Mammals Atlas in Kenya (MAKE); other useful Facebook page called (Mammals of the World); if you capture a species you cannot identify you can send it to us or post it to INATURALIST (site for posting information on biological resources if you want to be assisted to do it)

It looks like Karura Forest is a safe place now and it is possible to do research here. How big is this forest; its size. If its big enough then a good study can be conducted there at undergraduate and Masters level. I think students from universities would assist you to document the information which you may require. As government institution we may not have funding for research to support these students; but i think we can assist in designing the studies, and may be you could assist the student through FKF. 
On the suni issue; there two arguments from Mammals of Africa (published by Jonathan Kingdon) in 2013, has the following information. This information means in Kenya we have one species

Genus Nesotragus C. H. Smith, 1827 Suni
185.          Nesotragus moschatus Von Dueben, 1846. Suni
Restricted population ranges in E South Africa, Mozambique, SE Zimbabwe, S Malawi, Tanzania and Kenya, in thickets, forests and dense, evergreen woodlands. Widespread in the coastal strip, S-C Kenya (Hoffmann & Kingdon, 2013). 

But according to Groves, C.P. & P. Grubb (2011). Ungulate taxonomy. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore. There are two species of suni in Kenya or Africa:  Highland Suni-Neotragus kirchenpaueri (Pagenstecher, 1885) and lowland suni Neotragus moschatus Von Dueben, 1846. I would think that the suni you are capturing in your camera is the one restricted to highlands. It is not possible for the those in lowland Kenya to come to Karura, if i get your question. This suni in Karura has been isolated from those others in the lowland areas due to urbanization. It may be a species of suni or sub-species of the suni; but time will tell what it is as ungulates biologists come to agree. 

Yes please, lets continue talking and find a way in which we can continue this good science which i already happening.
Thank you and keep doing what you are doing; when or if you happen to visit the museum we can have a meeting and discuss more. I will also share your email with other mammalogists who may reply to you directly commenting on your good work of FKF. 
Keep well
Kind regards

Sunday, August 23, 2015

Dick Estes on Suni

From: Richard Estes <richarddestes@gmail.com>
Subject: Re: Karura Mammals
Date: 23 August 2015 21:21:26 GMT+3
To: Harvey Croze <hcroze@karurafriends.org>

Dear Harvey, 
It's good of you to include me among your array of experts on Kenya's flora and fauna, although my only experience with the East African coast is some months camping in the Shimba Hills while studying sable antelope in 1968 and 1969  
Your camera-trap photos are clearly suni: short, sturdy ringed horns, transparent rounded ears, and comparatively long tail.  Perhaps what makes some observers think it might be a duiker is the large preorbital glands that look a bit like duiker preorbs. The range and habitat are also well within suni distribution, as far as I know, having rarely seen and never actually studied this neotragine.   
Next time I'm in Kenya, perhaps a visit to Karura Forest Reserve could be arranged.  
Nice being back in touch with you,  Dick 

Saturday, August 22, 2015

Croze Approaches Experts


From: Harvey Croze <hcroze@karurafriends.org>
Subject: Karura Mammals
Date: 22 August 2015 12:28:54 GMT+3
To: "Thomas M. M. Butynski" <TButynski@aol.com>, Simon Musila <surnbirds@gmail.com>
Cc: Fleur Ng'weno <fleur@africaonline.co.ke>, Winnie Kiiru <winnie.kiiru@conservationkenya.org>, Karanja Njoroge <njokaranja@gmail.com>, Chantal Mariotte <chantal.mariotte@gmail.com>, Cristina Boelcke <cristina.boelcke@gmail.com>, Richard Estes <richarddestes@gmail.com>

Gentlemen,

Fleur Ng’weno suggested that I share with you some of the mammal information we are amassing in Karura Forest Reserve.  Actually, amassing is probably the correct term, since, apart from the very successful Colobus (Colobus guereza kikuyuensis) re-introductiion project with IPR, we have mainly been recording presence by means of PIR camera traps and adventitious sightings. So far, we have 20-odd species, ranging from the giant pouched rat to the bushpig. Smaller rodents, shrews and bats are unrepresented.

We all feel certain that there is so much that could be done in the forest, that it really is necessary to formulate systematic inventory and research strategies with like-minded experts and organisations such as yourselves, in your case for mammals.  Once we have such strategies, we feel confident that resources for further research could be found from outside sources. At the outset, I have to underscore that FKF is not a funding organisation, rather a donor recipient that has managed, with the concurrence of the KFS of course, to turn Karura into the impressive public asset it is today.

We have not yet, for example, explored in depth the statistically rather complex realm of mark-release-recapture population estimates using camera trap sitings. From what I understand, one needs a rather dense, systematic grid of cameras that could be well beyond our means. But perhaps you are aware of new, less equipment-intensive approaches that we could pursue. 

In the meanwhile, we are thinking of estimating relative proportions of species observed in order to establish some area-specfic baselines. Clearly, with the securing of the forest and now-zero-snaring, casual sightings are increasing and for some species occurring more in the daytime.  I’m sure that you can think of a host of other good things to do, using a judicious combination of your research staff and student candidates from the local universities.  Estimating of activity regimes using proportional sightings comes to mind.

The new edition of a video camera trap has brought to our attention something of which I was not aware: the importance of "canopy browsing" from the forest floor.  All three (or four!) species of antelopes are frequently observed feeding on fresh fallen canopy leaves. It seems to be all they do on-camera, apart from a bit of socialising. I suppose this is well-known to field mammalogists, although I’ve only seen passing mention, for example, by Kingdon with regard to the Blue Duiker. Harvey’s Duiker and the Grimm’s/Sunis in our video clips seem to go well beyond being merely ‘concentrate selectors’ of plant parts. I’m tempted to call them ‘growsers’, since they appear to get the bulk of their intake from fallen leaves.

And, since I have your attention, I wonder if I could get your take on the great Grimm’s Duiker-or-Suni debate that is raging here in the Karura. Well, perhaps raging is an exaggeration. A few of us are wondering... Does the Suni commonly stray upcountry out of the coastal forest range?   Are the little grey-brown antelopes all Grimm’s of varying ages, or do we have both species? We have camera trap shots of them, some of which you may see here: https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.531062820248929.117675.167946106560604&type=3&uploaded=9. Let me know what you think, and if you want more material to look at. And here are some recent shots of the Grimms/Suni that have taken up residence in some numbers at they newly-cleared site at Amani Garden:

Male 

Female
Allogrooming
Apologies for this long, rather random info dump. Kindly take this email as a preliminary introduction and request for further dialogue.  

You will note that I’ve copied this to some colleagues: Karanja Njoroge is the FKF Chairman; Chantal Mariotte is our Board member in charge of projects, such as the Colobus re-introduction; Dr. Winnie Kiiru has recently joined the FKF Board and will be concentrating on organisation of research; Cristina Boelcke is closely involved in forest management and fund-raising; Dick Estes needs no introduction!

Look forward to hear from you.

With best regards,



Tuesday, August 4, 2015

Fleur Ng'weno Starts It

Fleur Ng'weno kicked things off after we talked about mammals during, as it happened, one of her famous Wednesday morning birdwalks being held in Karura Forest...
On 4 Aug 2015, at 12:23, Fleur Ng'weno <fleur@africaonline.co.ke> wrote:

Dear Harvey

The following people would be delighted to get news of mammals in Karura
Forest. Please tell them I suggested that you write to them.

Tom Butynski <TButynski@aol.com>

Simon Musila <surnbirds@gmail.com> (at the Museum)

With best wishes from Fleur